Always very nerdy, sometimes a little gay.

My Blog List

Showing posts with label Star Wars. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Star Wars. Show all posts

Thursday, January 8

Welcome to 2009




I wasn't going to post about the casting of relatively unknown actor Matt Smith as the new Doctor, but since Wired have used it as an excuse for the flimsiest look at the eleven Doctors, I figured 'what the hell'...

My first response was shock at how young he was. The first seven Doctors were men when I was a child, David Tennant is about the same age as me, and now I'm seeing the Doctor played by someone almost young enough to be my child. Weird. However, incoming executive producer Steven Moffat has praised Smith for having a young/old quality which would be an important factor in playing the Doctor, and a second look at Smith confirms this. He's got an interesting face, and provided that his costume and behaviour are suitably different from Tennant, I don't see any reason why he can't work. The most fatal mistake would be for them to try and re-create Tennant, but as they say on the Outpost Gallifrey Doctor Who forum "in The Moff we trust". The production team have been doing everything right for four years, I doubt they're about to stuff up now. On a related note, I saw the Christmas special 'The Next Doctor' and it's great fun. Especially good to see Doctor Who finally get around to doing some proper steampunk.

I also saw The Clone Wars on Blu-ray. Now, I'm not one of those genre guys who rails against defiling of childhood treasures. If you've read my post on the latest Indiana Jones film, you'll know how benign my response was to that one. George Lucas' Star Wars prequels were all disappointments to varying degrees, but it doesn't bother me too much. I'm even pretty tolerant of the alterations he made to the original three films. Hell, when they seemingly destroyed Doctor Who for good with the 1996 telemovie, I didn't even bat an eye. And I find myself looking forward to J.J. Abrams' Star Trek more than I would have thought. The only defilement of a beloved story which really makes my blood boil is Brian Herbert's continuing exploitation of his father's Dune series, but even that one I usually just ignore. I'll always have Frank Herbert's original sextet of books, and nothing will take that away. I met Frank Herbert once - it was in 1985, about nine months before he died, and I got my movie tie in edition of his novel Dune signed by him. It's a memory I will always treasure. If I ever meet Brian Herbert, I will punch him in the face.

All of which is a windy prologue to my statement that The Clone Wars sucks, then blows, then sucks some more. The 2003 animated series was surprisingly good and more satisfying in a way than the prequel films. This one... where to begin? Anyone who knows anything about the Star Wars universe will find the main storyline - the Jedi Knights attempt to rescue the son of Jabba the Hutt from a separatist plot - about as plausible as if The Godfather II had a scene of Don Corleone imploring the US government for help. And those unfamiliar with Star Wars are shit out of luck - dumped into the middle of the clone war without a hint of setup or backstory, the only intro being a montage with an appalling newsreel style voice over, which plays like a scene from Starship Troopers without the satire. The storytelling - in terms of both visuals and dialogue - is so basic that it seems to be pitched at an audience that is just about ready to move on from the Teletubbies. Which is fine, although I'd argue that such an audience need not be confronted by the image of a Twi'lek whore dancing for the pleasure of a gross slug-like gangster lord. Dialogue is usually along the lines of 'protect Jabba's son' or 'we must keep those droids back' - bald statements of conflicts the audience are well aware of, and more than once a scene began with one character relating to another a description of the scene we just watched. The main dramatic conflict of the first ten minutes or so is a communications breakdown where a vital message ends up needing to conyeved in person. How thrilling is that?

No, The Clone Wars must rank as the least interesting Star Wars production - at least the notorious 1978 Star Wars Holiday Special had Harrison Ford! I nearly switched it off half way through, and in retrospect, my life would not have been any poorer if I had. I feel obliged to mention that the animation - a CG extension of the stylised characters from the 2003 show - is stunning, but here put to the service of a team of writers and a director who would struggle to tell the story of Goldilocks in a concise fashion. There are many, many, fan made Star Wars films with more compelling drama than this. One to avoid.

I really want to get around to reviewing The Mist, but I also got The Descent on Blu-ray for Christmas, and I reckon I'll end up writing about that one first. Second time around I loved it just as much - it's the genuine article, a scary horror film.

Saturday, October 25

Score of the week




Star Wars III: Revenge of the Sith
(John Williams, 2005)

This, the climax of George Lucas' Star Wars prequel trilogy, was one lame film. A classic case of join-the-dots storytelling. Even as fx house ILM reached greater heights with the types of environments and characters they could create, the script plumbed the lower depths of laziness. And just as Ewan McGregor catches the spirit of the young Kenobi and makes him the man we met in the original films, the other cast are resigning themselves to the fact that they are just parts of a machine. We get the Palpatine that Ian McDiarmid usually saves for Christmas parties, Samuel L. Jackson is clearly not engaged by the material as he was in the second film, and poor Natalie Portman can do nothing but watch her character turn into a series of plot devices, before being forced to act the most poorly conceived cinema death ever. George Lucas must have simply lost the will to write. Or bloody well direct, for that matter.

If only the hints dropped in the original trilogy (like Alec Guiness as Ben Kenobi wistfully recalling Luke's father) weren't so evocative, and hadn't had decades to grow in our imaginations. Many fans of the series could have (and probably did) pen superior third instalments. Lucas' insistence on filling in every possible gap (from the evolution of each type of spacecraft to not being able to resist explaining the Emperor's decrepit look in the original films, as if twenty years of abusing the dark side of the force wasn't enough) made it feel like watching a screenwriter run through a checklist of things he had to do. There was more excitement in the Pavlovian response the trailers generated - the right combination of R2 beep, Wookiee growl, laser zap, and bursts of John Williams and the LSO tweaking geek pressure points in anyone of a certain age. It's sad, because Attack of the Clones seemed to be a step in the right direction. Even The Phantom Menace has aged better than I suspect Sith will.

At least John Williams wasn't phoning it in. His score is full of beauty, action, adventure, and despair, even if it doesn't reach the heights of adrenaline as such cues as 'The Asteroid Field' from The Empire Strikes Back. The John Williams of the last, let's say, sixteen years is a different composer to the man who scored Superman, Raiders of the Lost Ark, or Dracula. He's a less excitable composer now - his instincts tend more towards subtlety. But he has not lost the capacity to produce thrilling music. Go on, give it a spin and tell me that 'Anakin vs Obi-Wan' is not a terrific action cue, or that the last two minutes of 'Anakin's Dark Deeds' is not beautiful and heartbreaking. Williams has become less prolific of late but when he does choose to work (because it must surely be always there for the asking for the most legendary living film composer) he always delivers something special.

Followers