Always very nerdy, sometimes a little gay.

My Blog List

Showing posts with label Doctor Who. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Doctor Who. Show all posts

Thursday, January 8

Welcome to 2009




I wasn't going to post about the casting of relatively unknown actor Matt Smith as the new Doctor, but since Wired have used it as an excuse for the flimsiest look at the eleven Doctors, I figured 'what the hell'...

My first response was shock at how young he was. The first seven Doctors were men when I was a child, David Tennant is about the same age as me, and now I'm seeing the Doctor played by someone almost young enough to be my child. Weird. However, incoming executive producer Steven Moffat has praised Smith for having a young/old quality which would be an important factor in playing the Doctor, and a second look at Smith confirms this. He's got an interesting face, and provided that his costume and behaviour are suitably different from Tennant, I don't see any reason why he can't work. The most fatal mistake would be for them to try and re-create Tennant, but as they say on the Outpost Gallifrey Doctor Who forum "in The Moff we trust". The production team have been doing everything right for four years, I doubt they're about to stuff up now. On a related note, I saw the Christmas special 'The Next Doctor' and it's great fun. Especially good to see Doctor Who finally get around to doing some proper steampunk.

I also saw The Clone Wars on Blu-ray. Now, I'm not one of those genre guys who rails against defiling of childhood treasures. If you've read my post on the latest Indiana Jones film, you'll know how benign my response was to that one. George Lucas' Star Wars prequels were all disappointments to varying degrees, but it doesn't bother me too much. I'm even pretty tolerant of the alterations he made to the original three films. Hell, when they seemingly destroyed Doctor Who for good with the 1996 telemovie, I didn't even bat an eye. And I find myself looking forward to J.J. Abrams' Star Trek more than I would have thought. The only defilement of a beloved story which really makes my blood boil is Brian Herbert's continuing exploitation of his father's Dune series, but even that one I usually just ignore. I'll always have Frank Herbert's original sextet of books, and nothing will take that away. I met Frank Herbert once - it was in 1985, about nine months before he died, and I got my movie tie in edition of his novel Dune signed by him. It's a memory I will always treasure. If I ever meet Brian Herbert, I will punch him in the face.

All of which is a windy prologue to my statement that The Clone Wars sucks, then blows, then sucks some more. The 2003 animated series was surprisingly good and more satisfying in a way than the prequel films. This one... where to begin? Anyone who knows anything about the Star Wars universe will find the main storyline - the Jedi Knights attempt to rescue the son of Jabba the Hutt from a separatist plot - about as plausible as if The Godfather II had a scene of Don Corleone imploring the US government for help. And those unfamiliar with Star Wars are shit out of luck - dumped into the middle of the clone war without a hint of setup or backstory, the only intro being a montage with an appalling newsreel style voice over, which plays like a scene from Starship Troopers without the satire. The storytelling - in terms of both visuals and dialogue - is so basic that it seems to be pitched at an audience that is just about ready to move on from the Teletubbies. Which is fine, although I'd argue that such an audience need not be confronted by the image of a Twi'lek whore dancing for the pleasure of a gross slug-like gangster lord. Dialogue is usually along the lines of 'protect Jabba's son' or 'we must keep those droids back' - bald statements of conflicts the audience are well aware of, and more than once a scene began with one character relating to another a description of the scene we just watched. The main dramatic conflict of the first ten minutes or so is a communications breakdown where a vital message ends up needing to conyeved in person. How thrilling is that?

No, The Clone Wars must rank as the least interesting Star Wars production - at least the notorious 1978 Star Wars Holiday Special had Harrison Ford! I nearly switched it off half way through, and in retrospect, my life would not have been any poorer if I had. I feel obliged to mention that the animation - a CG extension of the stylised characters from the 2003 show - is stunning, but here put to the service of a team of writers and a director who would struggle to tell the story of Goldilocks in a concise fashion. There are many, many, fan made Star Wars films with more compelling drama than this. One to avoid.

I really want to get around to reviewing The Mist, but I also got The Descent on Blu-ray for Christmas, and I reckon I'll end up writing about that one first. Second time around I loved it just as much - it's the genuine article, a scary horror film.

Saturday, December 13

Classic Who - 'The Robots of Death'


...from 1963 to K9, Doctor Who was important and from 1977 to 1989 it wasn't.

Kim Newman, in his book Doctor Who: A Critical Reading of the Series

Kim Newman blames Mary Whitehouse, K9 and Douglas Adams for what he refers to as the show's 'decline into cult nichedom', and I'd have to agree that if you wanted to find the moment where the original Doctor Who jumped the shark, it would have to be sometime during season 15. This coincided with the release of Star Wars raising the bar for audience expectations in science fiction film and television, but the elements for the decline of Doctor Who - such as incoming producer Graham Williams often finding himself second in authority to an increasingly garrulous Tom Baker, and script editor Douglas Adams emphasising humour to the detriment of the drama - were already in place. In the three years prior to this decline, however, the show was at its most popular - 'The Robots of Death' was watched by an average of 12 million viewers.

This four part story finds Tom Baker's Doctor and his new companion Leela (Louise Jameson) arriving on a sandminer cruising above the surface of a wind blasted desert planet and immediately becoming suspects in the recent murder of one of crew. The script by Chris Boucher (who had created the character of Leela for the previous story 'The Face of Evil' and would go on to write one more Doctor Who story - 'The Image of the Fendahl', another favourite) blends elements of Agatha Christie's Ten Little Indians and Isaac Asimov's Laws of Robotics with a splash of Dune. The clip here is from the opening of episode four:



Tom Baker was at his most comfortable in the role around this period, and 'The Robots of Death' finds him in peak form. Look at the confidence and humour he brings to his first line in the clip - rising from behind a bench in response to Uvanov's demand "what are you doing here?" with a smooth "why - does it upset you?" And Leela was the type of companion we'd not seen before, and would not see again - when Commander Uvanov slaps her early in the story, her response is "try that again, and I'll kill you where you stand!"

Louise Jameson as Leela.

This savage girl from a primitive tribe was prone to solving problems at knife-point, not exactly the most family audience-friendly character trait. The potential Pygmalion type development of her character was explored to an extent in a couple of subsequent stories - the following serial 'The Talons of Weng-Chiang' being the best example - but was pretty much forgotten in her second year - extended development of ongoing characters was not a strong suit of the original Doctor Who. This is only Leela's second story, so the character was still fresh and Boucher makes the most of her interactions with the Doctor and the world of the sandminer.

And it's this meticulously created world which really sets 'The Robots of Death' apart. It's crucial to keep in mind the resources the production team had access to when evaluating classic Who production values. With the sort of budgets and shooting schedules that would only just suffice for a production such as Home and Away or Neighbours, the Doctor Who production team had to create completely new settings each month - the story prior to 'Robots of Death' was set on a jungle planet, and the following story finds the Doctor and Leela in the fogbound streets of Victorian London. It's little wonder that cardboard tubing and aluminium foil were staples for construction of alien worlds and space stations.

Typically, the cast would rehearse an episode for four days before shooting, using brooms as weapons and creating control decks from upended furniture in the rehearsal room. Perhaps the inevitable sense of schoolyard play this engendered contributed to the unique tone of a lot of period Who. Then, on the Friday afternoon and evening, they would get into their costumes and enact the episode on the sets with the cameras rolling, with most scenes recorded as live straight to tape. Miniatures and other visual effects elements were often set up simultaneously in another section of the studio, and mixed in as live during the recording of scenes. When considering the constraints of this type of production, the ambition of the Doctor Who production team back in the day was truly remarkable. 

Here, the designs of the sets, costumes and even make-up are thoroughly thought out from the basis of this world being a society where humans genuinely take robots for granted, where everything a person could need done can be done by a robot. Thus the elaborate gowns, head-dress and facial makeup (echoing the design of the robot faces), far from being just typical overblown sci-fi silliness, are a logical extension of the type of leisure based society future speculation often depicted until the mid eighties. Around then it became apparent that we were going to use all of our technology to help us run around like chooks with our heads cut off, eventually leading to the frenetic dystopias of films such as Minority Report. One only needs to compare the design ethos of the 1977-1983 Star Wars films to the later prequel trilogy to see the sort of general effect this has had on futuristic design. It's doubtful that, had he depicted Coruscant in the original films, Lucas would have had Vegas style gambling strips and neon holographic advertising everywhere, for instance.

The design scheme for 'The Robots of Death' is followed through in the sets. Luxurious cushions and bed like sofas abound in the areas occupied by the humans, colour schemes are all soft earth tones, and abstract art adorns the corridors of the sandminer. This is a world based around humans relaxing - imagine art hanging in the walls of a mining machine! This vision of humanity gone soft goes some way to explaining the pathetic failure of Toos (Pamela Salem) to even attempt any sort of self defense in the clip - these are people for whom the disconnect from any form of true survival instinct has gone to an extreme.


A Voc class robot from 'The Robots of Death'.

And of course, we have the robots themselves - the jewel in the design crown. With their sculpted faces, silky smooth voices, and quilted vests, the robots are a triumph of art deco futurism. The design would be homaged - but not surpassed - in the 2007 Christmas special, 'Voyage of the Damned'.

Robot angel from 'Voyage of the Damned'.

The story of 'The Robots of Death' is perfectly paced out over the four episodes, and the characters have a bunch of interesting interpersonal conflicts and alliances which keep suspicion high, although the audience is privy all along to what's really going on. It's just about the perfect example of a Doctor Who story from the period - and it was immediately followed by 'The Talons of Weng-Chiang', another masterpiece and arguably one of the greatest achievements of the 26-year run of the show.

Friday, November 28

Score of the week




Of course, I think the new Doctor Who has been perfect from the very first episode. The minute Delia Derbyshire's cliffhanger scream played over the time vortex from the opening titles, I was instantly transported back to my childhood. The deal was sealed about twenty minutes into the first episode, when Rose Tyler (Billie Piper) ran toward the TARDIS yelling 'Doctor!'. This was the real deal, Doctor Who was back on telly, and it was fucking brilliant.

A more critical part of my brain, however, notices that the careful balance between barminess and adventure that Doctor Who needs to hit was very much a work in progress for the first two seasons. It might even be argued that the show only hit its stride when unburdened of the loaded relationship between Rose and the Doctor. The latest series in particular, buoyed by Catherine Tate taking the re-invention of the companion further than Billie Piper ever did, went from strength to strength, with perhaps the only duff episode being 'The Doctor's Daughter'.

Of course, the show couldn't have hit such diverse highs as 'The Unicorn and the Wasp', 'Midnight', or 'The Stolen Earth' without the careful build up of the first couple of seasons. The show needed Rose Tyler to lead up to Donna Noble. In a similar fashion, the music of Murray Gold started out pretty strong and developed into some of the best scoring we're currently hearing on the box. Series 1 was scored entirely with synthesizers and samples, which to an extent limited the effectiveness of some of the scoring, although some cues recalled the avant-garde electronica which was a staple of Doctor Who music in the 60s and 70s. As the popularity of the show has solidified, Gold has been given expanding resources to realise his scores, and is now able to utilise the BBC National Orchestra of Wales. His scores, like the show itself, vary wildly in styles and tone, and are never ashamed of big broad strokes.

This is the third soundtrack release for the series, presenting music from Series 4. It kicks off with Murray Gold's third (and best) reworking of the immortal Ron Grainer/Delia Derbyshire theme, with chugging guitar and high energy percussion propelling along Derbyshire's unearthly howls. Then we're treated to highlights from the material Murray Gold wrote for Series 4 - from the jaunty theme for Donna ('A Noble Girl About Town') through to action ('UNIT Rocks', 'The Dark and Endless Dalek Night') heartbreak ('The Rueful Fate of Donna Noble') and triumph ('Song of Freedom'). It's obvious that Murray Gold has been paying attention to Michael Giacchino's brilliant work for Lost, and elsewhere influences as diverse as John Murphy and Ennio Morricone can be heard, although Murray Gold definitely has his own distinct voice.

As with the previous two albums, Gold's music is better served here than in the show itself, where it often re-edited and tracked into different episodes, and frequently too prominent in the mix. This last problem has been rectified in Series 4, but the tracking of older cues remains an issue: the finale from the cue 'The Daleks', which fit the scene it was written for (the cliffhanger of the penultimate episode of Series 2, 'Army of Ghosts') like a glove, was far less suited to use in the Series 3 episode 'Evolution of the Daleks' and suffers even more by being repetitively tracked into several sequences in the Series 4 finale 'Journey's End'. I suspect these problems are more due to the producers of the show rather than decisions made by Gold.

But the album presentation is terrific, even though some of my favourite musical moments are not represented, such as the mime sequence from 'Partners In Crime', the introduction of Agatha Christie in 'The Unicorn and the Wasp', or the cliffhanger from 'The Silence in the Library'. But there was such a wealth of material composed for this series it's no wonder some good stuff had to get left off. The importance of Murray Gold's contribution to the show's success cannot be over-estimated. Doctor Who has always been an ever evolving beast, and the new incarnation has cleared such hurdles as the changing of Doctor and companion. With the show about to go through changes again, it will be interesting to see if Gold stays on - or if not, who would be capable of replacing him.

Friday, October 31

The Eleventh Doctor...


So the news has broken that David Tennant is moving on from Doctor Who once he finishes work on the five specials which are to be broadcast over 2009 and early 2010. Tennant's been sensational in the role, and his star and the profile of the show have ballooned in the three years he's been playing the Doctor. His Doctor must rank alongside the first four as a definitive interpretation (such is the magic of the character that there can be more than one definitive Doctor). So incoming executive producer/head writer Steven Moffat has a challenge finding the new Doctor. Who knows if they'll opt for an unkown, an established star, or a hot talent on the rise? If Moffat's previous stories for the show are any indication, his Doctor will be full of daring heroism and prone to romance. With that in mind, here are the people I hope they're talking to for the role...


ROBERT CARLYLE
I would love to see Carlyle in the TARDIS. Nervous energy? Check. Capable of a frightening edge? Check. Cheeky sex appeal? Check. He is perhaps a little over the age range I suspect they're looking for, but would nevertheless do a fantastic job. An increasingly high international profile and attachment to many projects in various stages of production means he may be too busy for the role. On the other hand, the man is the father of three, and may like to combine a rest from the hectic pace (although Doctor Who does have a particular brand of hectic pace all it's own) with the chance to do something his kids can watch. I'll call this one unlikely, much as I'd love to see it. Perhaps he can do a guest role sometime.


DYLAN MORAN
Dylan would be sensational - sadly, this being the enlightened future we live in, the Doctor would not be able to chain smoke or swill red wine - although Pertwee's Doctor didn't mind a nice red, so why not one every now and again? Moran does not do a great deal of film or television acting, and is apparently a very private man who prefers to stay out of the limelight, so if he was approached, he would most likely decline the role. Again, there must be a juicy guest role down the track for him.


JAMES McAVOY
Imagine James McAvoy in the role! I mean, this guy is the fucking shit, quite frankly. He's a bit on the young side, even for the current production team, and is so white hot at the moment that he'd be way too busy and they'd never afford him. Very unlikely to be approached. He'd be great though.


HUGH GRANT
Let me get this out of the way - I'm not a fan of Hugh Grant, and have not really liked much that he's been in. However, I would not be upset if he was approached for the role. I think his dopey charm would work well with a story like 'The Girl in the Fireplace'. His profile has waned in recent years, and he did lament in an interview a few years ago that he didn't get to play the Doctor, so who knows? At 48 years of age, he's perhaps a little old for the role, but I think this one is not outside the realms of possibility. Of course, you must realise that I'm indulging in a lot of speculation about the age range they'll be looking for, based on the history of the show, comments made by previous showrunner Russell T Davies, and the much written about grueling schedule of the show, but humour me, okay?


COLIN FIRTH
He busier than a one legged man in an arse kicking contest. Another one who's possibly a little old. So this one's a total fantasy pick, will never happen. So why's he on the list? Because once, just once, I'd like to see a smokin' hot Doctor. Sure, when I was but a confused 12 year old Peter Davison certainly had my heart racing, but now I can see that I was clutching at straws, and should have spent my time drooling over Matthew Waterhouse's Adric instead. Why? Three reasons: he was much closer to my age; he's gay (I know, as if I'd ever meet him, but at least it makes the chances slightly better); and he's aged into one of those really cute grey haired guys in their mid forties. Before you jump to conclusions about my opinion of Adric, I want to make a few of things clear. Back in the day, I never looked at him twice. His character was poorly served throughout his tenure on the show, and quite possibly just a bad idea. And Matthew Waterhouse cannot act - or could not back then at least. He literally made a showcase of bad acting simply walking across the room in the otherwise superb story 'State of Decay'. Anyway, back to the point: it'd really make me happy to have a Doctor who made me think dirty thoughts.


ALFRED MOLINA
Again, with the never-gonna-happen. IMDb has him listed for at least eight or nine features in production for release over the next two years. He's here because he became my number one choice for the role when I saw the passion, energy, and madness that he brought to the role of Otto Octavius in Spiderman 2.


JOANNA LUMLEY
I don't think she's an example of never-gonna-happen. Ms. Lumley is an example of never say never. The idea of a female Doctor bothers me not in the slightest, and it would at least mean we'd be more likely to get some hot boys in the TARDIS along for the ride as companions. She's already played the role anyway, in the 1999 Comic Relief sketch 'The Curse of Fatal Death' - from a funny and clever script by one Steven Moffat, which featured Rowan Atkinson as the Doctor with Julia Sawalha as his companion Emma facing off against Jonathan Pryce's Master. The climax had the Doctor successively regenerate through Jim Broadbent, Richard E. Grant, and Hugh Grant to finally arrive at Joanna Lumley, who takes off in the TARDIS with Sawalha in tow. Lumley has said she'd love to return to the world of Doctor Who, but only if offered the title role. I say, why not? She was great in 'Fatal Death' and the climax of series 4 showed - with Catherine Tate and her character Donna Noble - that a female Doctor could be sensational. Would love to see this happen. It would be more likely to be in the form of a one episode special rather than handing the show over to her, however.

Followers